I think one of the main reasons why it is difficult
for students to transition from oral language to written academic language is
because the latter is like a whole new language of its own. Written academic language has rules, a format
and vocabulary that is different from spoken language and new writers
regardless of their backgrounds all have to lean these differences. I know as a
native speaker of English that when I first started academic writing I would write
what I would say right on the page. I still have to edit my writing to make sure
I am not breaking this rule. Another difficulty is being aware that you should
not use idiomatic expressions or contractions in academic writing. These are
all things that novice writers have to learn through their composition classes
and other writings they do in class. One of my graduate professors helped me
think in terms of writing academically by calling it an economy of words. I
believe there is a book by the same name, but just that title has helped me be
mindful of the words I use in my papers as a writing student.
I think generation 1.5 students probably have the
most difficulty moving from informal oral language to that of academic writing
because they could have gaps in their education and may not have had formal
grammar instruction. They have also acquired English primarily through
listening to the language so it would feel natural to just write what they have
heard in their papers. I think international students may also have some
difficulty with this transition because they haven’t had many opportunities
with using English orally. Combined with being unfamiliar with the structure of
written academic English these students are learning how to write through trial
and error and may incorporate what they hear into their writing.
I would explain to all novice writers that learning
academic language is similar to learning a new language and that it is a
process that every writer has to go through to become skillful. I would use my
difficulties with making the transition to academic writing as examples of
what is acceptable and what is not in written essays. I would urge my students
and tutees to become familiar with academic vocabulary through actively reading
and making note of common words that are used in their given disciplines. I
would have my students write early and often to get them used to writing academically
and remind them that they can learn from their mistakes.
I love the idea of an economy of words. I feel like this is one of my biggest challenges as a writer too.
ReplyDelete